ACT English: Which vs. That

Use which, with commas, for extra information the sentence could do without. Use that, with no commas, for information the sentence needs. On ACT English, the commas usually decide the question.

For StudentsEducators2 min readUpdated

On this page
  1. What's the rule for which vs. that?
  2. Does which need a comma on the ACT?
  3. What other trap does ACT set with which?
  4. Does the ACT test which and that?
  5. Which vs. that practice questions
  6. How should you practice which vs. that?
  7. Official ACT resources

What's the rule for which vs. that?

  • Which adds extra information, set off by commas: "Their impact, which began modestly, now extends into nearly every aspect of society." Take the clause out, and the sentence still means the same thing.
  • That adds information the sentence needs, with no commas: "The practice tests that ACT posts online are free." Take it out, and the sentence means all practice tests.

Does which need a comma on the ACT?

Yes, when it starts a clause of extra information in the middle or at the end of a sentence: a comma before it, and another after the clause if the sentence goes on. That never takes a comma before it. After a preposition, it's which, as in "each of which"; see who vs. whom for people.

What other trap does ACT set with which?

A which clause can't be the main verb. If turning "technology has expanded" into "technology, which has expanded" leaves the sentence with no main verb, the which is wrong, as in the second question below.

Does the ACT test which and that?

Yes, as punctuation and sentence structure, both in the English section's Conventions of Standard English category, which makes up 38 to 43% of the section. The choices often differ only by which, that and their commas.

Which vs. that practice questions

Two questions from Reach's question bank. Give yourself about 1½ minutes, the real test's pace for two questions.

EnglishQuestion 1 of 2

Ultimately, the computer’s evolution demonstrates humanity’s relentless drive to innovate. From sprawling machines to sleek smartphones, computers are both marvels of engineering and essential tools for daily life. Their impact, which began modestly, now extends into nearly every aspect of society.

Given the sentence above, choose the best replacement for the underlined portion:

Show the answer

The answer is A: which began modestly, now extends.

EnglishQuestion 2 of 2

The ongoing evolution of digital technology has expanded creative possibilities, enabling instant experimentation and editing. Despite vast changes in equipment and techniques, the fundamental power of photography remains the same: to preserve moments and tell stories.

Which choice most effectively and correctly punctuates the underlined portion?

Show the answer

The answer is A: NO CHANGE.

See how to solve them
  1. Computers (A, NO CHANGE). "Which began modestly" adds extra information about "their impact," so it sits between two commas. B drops the commas, and C and D use "that," which never takes commas around it.
  2. Technology (A, NO CHANGE). The sentence needs its main verb: "the evolution of digital technology has expanded creative possibilities." B turns that verb into a which clause, so the sentence has no main verb left. C adds a second subject with no link, and D's "as expanded" isn't a verb.

How should you practice which vs. that?

Each time which or that is underlined, cover the clause and ask whether the sentence still says what it means. Then check that the sentence still has a main verb. Work full passages at about 42 seconds a question, the pace in our guide to how to study for ACT English.

Reach turns English practice into short games on your phone, and keeps you practicing the kinds of questions you miss, paced to your goal score and test date. It's free to try, then $10 a month.

Official ACT resources

ACT® is a registered trademark of ACT Education Corp. Reach Test Prep isn’t affiliated with ACT. Spotted something out of date? Email reach@reachtestprep.org.